Fire and rehire reform: What employers need to know
13th October, 2026
Employment Law Digest
1st November 2026
Employment Law Digest November 2026: Case law update
Find out more
30th October 2026
Employment Rights Act 2025: Right to access in the workplace and duty to inform employees of their trade union rights
Find out more
26th October 2026
Fee waiver rule changes from 8 October 2026: What employers need to know about Right to Work checks
Find out more
15th October 2026
Extended Employment Tribunal time limits: Why record-keeping matters
Find out more
13th October 2026
Fire and rehire reform: What employers need to know
Find out more
The Employment Rights Act 2025 (ERA 2025) received Royal Assent on 18 December 2025. Among its reforms is a fundamental change to the law on dismissal and re-engagement, colloquially referred to as "fire and rehire".
Described by the government as “the biggest upgrade to workers’ rights in a generation”, the ERA 2025 introduces new protections making it automatically unfair to dismiss employees refusing to agree to “restricted variations” to their employment contracts.
Where are we now?
Presently, an employer wishing to change employment terms and conditions generally has three options:
- Reach an agreement with the employee to change by consent
- Push through the changes unilaterally, for which there may be consequences for breach of contract
- Dismiss the employee, with notice, and immediately offer re-engagement on new terms.
That’s been the way for as long as many of us can remember, and employers and employees know where they stand.
In 2024 a Code of Practice was introduced, primarily to deal with the third option. The Code sought to inform employers on procedural fairness and stresses dismissal should only be used as a last resort, with meaningful and timely consultation and agreement being the preferred choice.
All that will change, and with it some potential implications when dealing with the renewal of fixed term contracts, redundancy procedures and if TUPE isn’t complex enough, for future outsourcing arrangements. January 2027 was the expected timeline for implementing these changes; it is now March 2027. The government has now published a draft revised statutory Code of Practice on Dismissal and Re-engagement (2026 Code), along with an accompanying consultation. That consultation runs until 17 December 2026.
The draft 2026 Code is intended to provide practical guidance for employers considering dismissal and re-engagement (or dismissal and replacement), guiding them through information-sharing and meaningful consultation. Once finalised, the 2026 Code, will replace the 2024 Code and reflect the changes to be made by section 28 ERA 2025.
With the 2024 Code being withdrawn in March 2027, and the 2026 Code coming into play in summer 2027, there will be an interim period to which no code seemingly will apply. That’s a development to watch carefully, as currently a failure to follow the code can result in an uplift to the compensatory award in relevant unfair dismissal cases.
So, whilst little may currently be known about Section 28 of the 2025 Act, it won’t be long before Board level and senior decision makers, HR teams and those having management responsibilities become all too familiar with its application, and its implications.
What is Section 28 of the ERA 2025 Act?
Section 28 of the ERA 2025 introduces three new provisions into the Employment Rights Act 1996 (ERA 1996) covering dismissal where an employee does not agree to certain contractual changes. The new sections, 104I, 104J and 104K, cover restricted contractual variations, other contractual variations and the replacement of employees with non-employees.
What will the changes mean for employers?
The key risk for employers under Section 28 will be automatically unfair dismissals. In particular, sections 104I and 104K introduce new protections where an employee is dismissed because they have refused certain contractual changes, or where an employer seeks to replace them following a refusal.
Restricted variations
Section 104I applies where the reason, or principal reason, for an employees’ dismissal is either:
- the employee refused to agree to the restricted variation; or
- the employer sought to re-engage that employee, or replace them with another employee, under a contract that includes a restricted variation.
In both scenarios the dismissal will be automatically unfair. There are exemptions to this if the employer can prove financial difficulty, but they are limited, and in most scenarios will not apply.
Restricted variations originally included changes to:
- pay or the way an employee’s work or performance is measured
- pension terms
- the number of working hours
- the timing and duration of shift arrangements
- the amount of time off an employee is entitled to take
The government recently added to this list, confirming that certain expenses and benefits will fall within the scope of restricted variations. These include certain types of travel expenses, (including mileage), accommodation expenses and accommodation as a benefit in kind.
Similarly, for shift patterns, restricted variations will be limited to changes from day to night working (or vice versa) and weekday to weekend working (or vice versa). Night-time is to be defined as 11.00 pm to 6.00 am which is in line with the definition of night-time working in the Working Time Regulations 1998.
A contractual term which allows an employer to make one of those changes without the employee’s agreement can also amount to a restricted variation. Important to note is the definition of sums payable to an employee does not require the payment to be made by the employer. This means it could encompass all manner of third-party payments from permanent health insurance payments to tips received from customers.
There is a limited exception where an employer can demonstrate that the restricted variation was necessary to address significant financial difficulties affecting, or likely to affect, its ability to continue as an ongoing concern, and that the need for the variation could not reasonably have been avoided. For public sector employees, the test relates to the financial sustainability of carrying out statutory functions.
Even when this exception applies, the dismissal must still be considered under the ordinary unfair dismissal test, including factors such as the consultation undertaken, and anything offered to the employee in return for agreeing to the variation.
Other contractual changes
Section 104J deals with non-restricted contractual variations. Here there is no automatically unfair dismissal, but rather a series of considerations for a tribunal to apply when determining the fairness, or otherwise, of a dismissal. Again this applies when an employee does not accept the contractual change, or the employer is looking to re-engage that employee or replace them with another.
By way of example changes to share schemes will not be restricted variations.
Replacing employees with non-employees
Section 104K deals with situations where an employer dismisses employees with a view to replacing them with a non-employee, such as an agency worker or self-employed contractor to carry out the same or substantially the same duties.
In these circumstances, the dismissal will also be automatically unfair, subject to a similar limited exception where the employer can demonstrate significant difficulties and that the replacement could not have been avoided.
Practical implications for employers to consider
The changes represent a significant shift from the current legal position. At present, an employer can fairly dismiss an employee for refusing to accept varied terms provided the employer has sound business reasons and has acted within the range of reasonable responses. The changes do not require the variation to be crucial to business survival. Under the new framework, some dismissals that are currently fair will in many cases no longer be so.
Where an employer seeks to rely on the financial difficulty exception tribunals will need to consider the employers financial position, its ability to continue as a going concern, and whether the contractual variation could reasonably have been avoided. Employers may therefore need to provide detailed financial evidence to support their position.
Realistically most scenarios requiring contractual changes will not be due to financial hardship, but for ordinary commercial reasons required when running a business. These too will need to be considered under the new framework. This may affect an employer’s bargaining position where employees and their representatives are aware that dismissal has become riskier for employers and may feel emboldened to resist detrimental changes. This will be compounded by the removal of the cap next year on unfair dismissal compensation, making it difficult for employers to assess the cost of dismissing in these circumstances.
Employers should also be aware of the potential implications beyond traditional fire and rehire situations, including redundancies, the correction of contractual errors when preparing a written contract, non-renewal of fixed term contracts and renewal on different terms, and the introduction of additional rights where employers seek to dismiss and re-engage as part of a TUPE outsourcing. Whilst the ERA 2025 will soon reduce the qualifying service period from 2 years to 6 months, employees who do not meet this service threshold under TUPE could in theory, be able to pursue a claim under section 104l for automatically unfair dismissal.
So, from spring next year, a seismic change is coming meaning the time for employers to understand the reforms, and their implications, is most definitely now.
Employment Rights Act check-up
Please note that this briefing is designed to be informative, not advisory and represents our understanding of English law and practice as at the date indicated. We would always recommend that you should seek specific guidance on any particular legal issue.
This page may contain links that direct you to third party websites. We have no control over and are not responsible for the content, use by you or availability of those third party websites, for any products or services you buy through those sites or for the treatment of any personal information you provide to the third party.
Topics:
Follow us on LinkedIn
Keep up to date with all the latest updates and insights from our expert team